For Subscribers

How to Win Over Dissatisfied Customers Some people aren't nice when they don't love your product. But you can change them. All you need is a little psychology.

By Jason Feifer

This story appears in the October 2019 issue of BIZ Experiences. Subscribe »

Nigel Parry

We're told that we should love customer service. We're told that, as BIZ Experiencess, our passion should be to make people happy. We're here to serve, to solve problems, to spread joy! And that's all true. Good customer service can also be good fun. It's a blast to help someone enjoy the thing you've made.

But let's be honest: Sometimes customer service is not pleasant. Because sometimes people are not pleasant. And that's when we, as BIZ Experiencess, need to kick into a different gear. We need something to help us stay focused -- to not get dragged down by frustration.

Related: Need to Make A Change? Do It Immediately!

In short, we need a reminder of what people really want.

When I hear from an angry or unpleasant customer, I play a little game. My goal is to disarm them -- to rid them of their anger so thoroughly that, frankly, they're embarrassed to have been so angry at all. This is possible! It's not even that complicated. All I have to do is make them feel heard, because that is what they want most. When you hear them, they will transform. It's magical.

I'll give you a recent example. After the previous issue of BIZ Experiences magazine, a reader sent me a terse note to complain about a story he didn't like. This happens with some regularity; it's impossible to please everyone. And this person's email followed the typical format from an upset reader: He insulted the magazine, stridently made his point, and then capped it off with a threat: "I won't be re-subscribing," he wrote.

I have a theory about emails like this. Yes, sure, sometimes a person is genuinely unhinged, and there's no point in trying to reason with them. But most people are reasonable. They're not boiling with untamed rage. Instead, they simply don't expect a response. They don't believe that I (or you, or anyone) will actually listen to them, and they're preemptively frustrated by that. Imagine it this way: They're walking up to a door, and they're convinced they won't be let in. So what do they do? They bring a battering ram.

Related: You're Not Approachable Enough. Let's Fix That.

This is why, whenever I see an angry email like the one I just received, I drop whatever I'm doing to respond. I want to catch them off guard. They don't expect me to reply, and they certainly don't expect me to reply quickly. So I do -- and I always write an email that acknowledges what they said, and then, in a nondefensive way, explains my point of view. I never say they're wrong. I just explain why I made the decision I made.

"Thank you for your feedback," began my response to that upset reader. "We work hard to make a magazine that we hope will be enlightening and informative and surprising for BIZ Experiencess, and, in doing so, we take our cues from BIZ Experiencess themselves: We know that BIZ Experiencess are great risk-takers and experimenters, and so we, too, want to try out new ideas and see how they land." Then I explained that we took a risk by making the story he didn't like. Some people liked it; others may not have. I can appreciate that, I said.

A few hours later, the angry reader wrote me back. "Thanks for your reply," he began. "I didn't expect one." (See? Told you.) Then he reiterated his point, but softer this time. At the end, he wrote: "Thanks for listening."

Related: You're Not Approachable Enough. Let's Fix That.

I asked the reader if he was otherwise satisfied with the magazine. He said he was. So then, curious to see what would happen, I asked him why he was going to unsubscribe simply because there was one story in one issue that he didn't like. I told him I was genuinely curious; I wanted to understand him, as our customer. His response: "Sometimes I use hyperbole for effect."

In other words, he's not canceling. Maybe he never planned to. Maybe I talked him out of it. Either way, I succeeded. And he seemed a little sheepish for coming at me so hard.

I have to admit: I find this very satisfying. It's fun to disarm someone! But more important, it's valuable to see how many bridges can be crossed, and how many gaps can be filled, simply by listening. We live in a world full of loud, angry voices. We'll never win by adding another loud, angry voice to the mix. But hearing people out? Opening the door, even when they've brought a battering ram? That's where change really happens. And that matters.

Jason Feifer

BIZ Experiences Staff

Editor in Chief

Jason Feifer is the editor in chief of BIZ Experiences magazine and host of the podcast Problem Solvers. Outside of BIZ Experiences, he writes the newsletter One Thing Better, which each week gives you one better way to build a career or company you love. He is also a startup advisor, keynote speaker, book author, and nonstop optimism machine.

Want to be an BIZ Experiences Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Business Ideas

70 Small Business Ideas to Start in 2025

We put together a list of the best, most profitable small business ideas for BIZ Experiencess to pursue in 2025.

Starting a Business

These Brothers Started a Business to Improve an Everyday Task. They Made Their First Products in the Garage — Now They've Raised Over $100 Million.

Coulter and Trent Lewis had an early research breakthrough that helped them solve for the right problem.

Business News

Codie Sanchez's BizScout Announces the Appointment of Bobby Graham as President

Graham will lead operations, growth, and platform development for the fast-growing business acquisition marketplace.

Business News

Here Are the 10 Jobs AI Is Most Likely to Automate, According to a Microsoft Study

These careers are most likely to be affected by generative AI, based on data from 200,000 conversations with Microsoft's Copilot chatbot.

Business News

Starbucks Built a New 'Luxury' Office Near Its CEO's Newport Beach, California Home

The 4,624-square-foot office was disclosed as part of Starbucks CEO Brian Niccol's compensation package before he started the role last fall.

Business News

Mars Says 94% of Its Products Sold in the U.S. are Now Made There, Too

The candy-maker has created 9,000 jobs over the last five years with its investments, according to a new report.