The Best Domains Are Gone — But Here's How Savvy Founders Still Snag Them Why do so many founders fail to land premium domains? Because the best ones are already taken, priced sky-high and nearly impossible to secure — unless you know how to play the game.
By Michael Gargiulo Edited by Maria Bailey
Key Takeaways
- Founders looking for a premium domain can't afford to go it alone. A domain broker brings insider access, negotiation skills and the expertise to close the deal right.
Opinions expressed by BIZ Experiences contributors are their own.
Getting a premium domain isn't just a branding decision — it's a strategic asset. The right domain builds instant credibility, drives trust and can drastically reduce long-term marketing costs.
The problem? The best names aren't sitting around unclaimed. They're owned, guarded and in high demand. And when they do hit the market, they're often priced in the six- to seven-figure range.
That leaves founders with a choice: navigate the domain minefield alone or hire a broker who knows how to win high-stakes digital real estate deals.
Here's why that decision matters — and how to approach it strategically.
What makes a domain "premium" — and why it matters
Premium domains are short, memorable, easy to spell and usually end in .com. Think Stripe.com, Tesla.com, or Voice.com. Some are exact-match keywords like Insurance.com, others are powerful brand names.
These domains aren't just easy to remember — they signal legitimacy, authority and long-term vision. A great domain improves brand recall, boosts SEO, and lowers customer acquisition costs. That's why companies often spend millions acquiring them.
It's not just a name — it's trust at first sight.
Why founders struggle to secure premium domains
1. Premium domains are already taken: Unlike social handles, domains can't just be claimed. Most of the best .coms were bought years ago — often by investors or companies who know their value and aren't eager to sell.
2. Interest drives up price fast: If a domain owner senses a high-growth startup is interested, the price can skyrocket. Elon Musk famously paid $11 million for Tesla.com — but that deal would've cost far more had he negotiated directly without anonymity.
3. Poor negotiation can backfire: Without experience or leverage, founders risk signaling desperation. That can double the asking price — or kill the deal entirely.
4. Transfers are complicated and risky: Even after a deal is made, getting the domain safely transferred involves contracts, escrow and legal protection. One misstep can cost a fortune.
Why domain brokers give founders an edge
A great broker doesn't just make introductions — they bring strategy, discretion and negotiating power.
- Off-market access: Top brokers often know about domains that aren't publicly listed and can unlock private deals others can't.
- Anonymity: Sellers don't know who the buyer is, eliminating emotional markups or inflated expectations.
- Speed and structure: Founders don't have time for slow back-and-forth. Brokers drive the deal, navigate seller psychology and close fast.
- Creative financing: From lease-to-own models to equity trades, brokers know how to structure win-win deals when cash isn't the only currency.
What happens when you go it alone
Trying to acquire a premium domain solo often leads to:
- Overpaying by two to three times more due to inexperience or lack of anonymity.
- Losing the deal to faster, better-prepared buyers.
- Legal mistakes that put your money — or your domain — at risk.
- Settling for a second-tier domain that weakens your brand for years.
Related: 5 Unforgettable Lessons I Learned Spending $1 Million on a Domain Name
What to look for in a broker
If you're hiring a domain broker, make sure they bring:
- A proven track record of high-value, successful deals.
- Transparent fees — no vague commissions or surprise markups.
- Industry access and relationships that open doors.
- Clear communication and experience with legal, escrow and brand protection.
In 2025, your domain is your identity
As AI, crypto and global e-commerce scale, digital real estate is becoming scarcer and more valuable. The best names are being scooped up by startups, holding companies and corporations with cash to spend.
If you're building a serious business, don't leave your domain strategy to chance. A great name can elevate your brand. The wrong one, or worse, missing out on the right one, can hold you back for years.
Smart founders treat domain acquisition like M&A: strategic, high-impact and worth getting right.
